Customer Reviews

★★★★★

4.5 out of 5

Based on 309 reviews

★★★★★
Series

"Very well done. It kept my interest and was well balanced. The subject matter was meaningful to me as I was a big fan of The Frugal Gourmet show and cookbooks. The balance of good and evil has kept me thinking for days. Huge moral issues are introduced; issues that apply not only to the people in the documentary, but to all of us struggling with life's choices."

Kathleen

★★★★★
Series

"Very nostalgic - Jeff Smith ignited my interest in cooking long ago and I still love it. I thought it was a nice unbiased chronicle of his life and I learned interesting details about Smith I could have never guessed."

Charice

★★★★★
Series

"I found the docs series to be well done and a very enlightening view of Jeff Smith."

Deb

★★★★★
Series

"It was very good but it made me so sad. I learned so much from his tv shows and books. I was an avid fan. If times were what they are today maybe he would have felt that he could come out of the closet early and things could have been different. Maybe i’m calloused to it now i don’t know. I just feel lingering sadness for the victims and for Jeff. His legacy has been so tainted. What a loss …"

Sandy

★★★★★
Series

"I loved watching The Frugal Gourmet in the 1980s. I rarely missed an episode. Jeff was a character and very engaging. Although I am very sickened and disappointed in where life took him and the damage he created for many people, I do believe he was a good person in many ways. His demons eventually took over and made him who he eventually became. Such a sad ending for a man who seemingly had everything."

Julie

★★★★★
Series

"We always wondered what happened, and now we know. If your looking for a feel good nostalgia trip with a happy ending, this is not it."

Tim Carpenter

★★★★★
Series

"IBYP is very informative and honest. Back in the day, I was a frequent viewer of The Frugal Gourmet series and bought or was gifted many of his cookbooks. I am now feeling some buyers remorse for having supported him. I wish the process of getting it to play on my TV was a bit more intuitive. (Note: I am an experienced smartphone and computer user.)"

Markg92

★★★★★
Series

"I really enjoyed it more than I thought I would! It was very well done."

D

★★★★★
Series

"Jeff Smith was a complicated fellow this documentary tackles the dilemma of duality in the human condition magnificently. Jeff's genius and generosity juxtaposed to his abuse, alcoholism and manipulation. Poignant and factual at the same time. Walks the line brilliantly. BRAVO"

Monica Stiles

★★★★★
Series

"This series thoroughly detailed Smith's knowledge and talents through the years. All the people interviewed, who worked with and for him, were very interesting. All in all the outcome is the same...he was a sexual predator who groomed and assaulted many young boys, paid them off with millions, and died of his own natural causes with no criminal charges ever brought against him. Sad and shameful."

Cat

★★★★★
Series

"Pretty good. Some what dry."

B J

★★★★★
Series

"I thought it was well done and interesting"

Kathy